Mark Needham

Thoughts on Software Development

Python: scikit-learn/lda: Extracting topics from QCon talk abstracts

with one comment

Following on from Rik van Bruggen’s blog post on a QCon graph he’s created ahead of this week’s conference, I was curious whether we could extract any interesting relationships between talks based on their abstracts.

Talks are already grouped by their hosting track but there’s likely to be some overlap in topics even for talks on different tracks.
I therefore wanted to extract topics and connect each talk to the topic that describes it best.

My first attempt was following an example which uses Non-Negative Matrix factorization which worked very well for extracting topics but didn’t seem to provide an obvious way to work out how to link those topics to individual talks.

Instead I ended up looking at the lda library which uses Latent Dirichlet Allocation and allowed me to achieve both goals.

I already had some code to run TF/IDF over each of the talks so I thought I’d be able to feed the matrix output from that into the LDA function. This is what I started with:

import csv
 
from sklearn.feature_extraction.text import TfidfVectorizer, CountVectorizer
from sklearn.decomposition import NMF
from collections import defaultdict
from bs4 import BeautifulSoup, NavigableString
from soupselect import select
 
def uri_to_file_name(uri):
    return uri.replace("/", "-")
 
sessions = {}
with open("data/sessions.csv", "r") as sessions_file:
    reader = csv.reader(sessions_file, delimiter = ",")
    reader.next() # header
    for row in reader:
        session_id = int(row[0])
        filename = "data/sessions/" + uri_to_file_name(row[4])
        page = open(filename).read()
        soup = BeautifulSoup(page)
        abstract = select(soup, "div.brenham-main-content p")
        if abstract:
            sessions[session_id] = {"abstract" : abstract[0].text, "title": row[3] }
        else:
            abstract = select(soup, "div.pane-content p")
            sessions[session_id] = {"abstract" : abstract[0].text, "title": row[3] }
 
corpus = []
titles = []
for id, session in sorted(sessions.iteritems(), key=lambda t: int(t[0])):
    corpus.append(session["abstract"])
    titles.append(session["title"])
 
n_topics = 15
n_top_words = 50
n_features = 6000
 
vectorizer = TfidfVectorizer(analyzer='word', ngram_range=(1,1), min_df = 0, stop_words = 'english')
matrix =  vectorizer.fit_transform(corpus)
feature_names = vectorizer.get_feature_names()
 
import lda
import numpy as np
 
vocab = feature_names
 
model = lda.LDA(n_topics=20, n_iter=500, random_state=1)
model.fit(matrix)
topic_word = model.topic_word_
n_top_words = 20
 
for i, topic_dist in enumerate(topic_word):
    topic_words = np.array(vocab)[np.argsort(topic_dist)][:-n_top_words:-1]
    print('Topic {}: {}'.format(i, ' '.join(topic_words)))

And if we run it?

Topic 0: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 1: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 2: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 3: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 4: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 5: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 6: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 7: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 8: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 9: 10 faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 10: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 11: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 12: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 13: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 14: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 15: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 16: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 17: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 18: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure
Topic 19: zoosk faced exposing expression external externally extra extraordinary extreme extremes face facebook facilitates faster factor factors fail failed failure

As you can see, every topic has the same set of words which isn’t what we want. Let’s switch out our TF/IDF vectorizer for a simpler count based one:

vectorizer = CountVectorizer(analyzer='word', ngram_range=(1,1), min_df = 0, stop_words = 'english')

The rest of the code stays the same and these are the topics that get extracted:

Topic 0: time people company did writing real way used let cassandra soundcloud successful know web organization audio lives swift stuck
Topic 1: process development delivery platform developer continuous testing rapidly deployment implementing release demonstrate paas advice hard light predictable radically introduce
Topic 2: way open space kind people change meetings ll lead powerful practice times everyday simple qconlondon organization unconference track extraordinary
Topic 3: apache apis processing open spark distributed leading making environments solr cases brooklyn components existing ingestion contributing data target evolved
Topic 4: management million effective cost halo gameplay player billion ad catastrophic store microsoft final music influence information launch research purchased
Topic 5: product look like use talk problems working analysis projects challenges 2011 functionality useful spread business deep inside happens sensemaker
Topic 6: ll computers started principles free focus face smaller atlas control uses products avoid computing ground billions mean volume consistently
Topic 7: code end users developers just application way line apps mobile features sites hours issues applications write faster game better
Topic 8: ve development teams use things world like time learned lessons think methods multiple story say customer developer experiences organisations
Topic 9: software building docker built challenges monitoring gilt application discuss solution decision talk download source center critical decisions bintray customers
Topic 10: years infrastructure tools language different service lot devops talk adoption scala popular clojure advantages introduced effectively looking wasn includes
Topic 11: high does latency session requirements functional performance real world questions problem second engineering patterns gravity explain discuss expected time
Topic 12: business make build technology technologies help trying developers parts want interfaces small best centres implementations critical moo databases going
Topic 13: need design systems large driven scale software applications slow protocol change needs approach gets new contracts solutions complicated distributed
Topic 14: architecture service micro architectures increasing talk microservices order market value values new present presents services scalable trading practices today
Topic 15: java using fast robovm lmax ios presentation really jvm native best exchange azul hardware started project slowdowns goal bring
Topic 16: data services using traditional create ways support uk large user person complex systems production impact art organizations accessing mirage
Topic 17: agile team experience don work doing processes based key reach extra defined pressure machines nightmare practices learn goals guidance
Topic 18: internet new devices programming things iot big number deliver day connected performing growing got state thing provided times automated
Topic 19: cloud including deploy session api government security culture software type attack techniques environment digital secure microservice better creation interaction

Some of the groupings seem to make sense e.g. Topic 11 contains words related to high performance code with low latency; Topic 15 covers Java, the JVM and other related words; but others are more difficult to decipher

e.g. both Topic 14 and Topic 19 talk about micro services but the latter mentions ‘government’ and ‘security’ so perhaps the talks linked to that topic come at micro services from a different angle altogether.

Next let’s see which topics a talk is most likely to be about. We’ll look at the first ten:

doc_topic = model.doc_topic_
for i in range(0, 10):
    print("{} (top topic: {})".format(titles[i], doc_topic[i].argmax()))
    print(doc_topic[i].argsort()[::-1][:3])
 
To the Moon (top topic: 8)
[ 8  0 11]
Evolutionary Architecture and Micro-Services - A Match Enabled by Continuous Delivery (top topic: 14)
[14 19 16]
How SoundCloud uses Cassandra (top topic: 0)
[0 6 5]
DevOps and the Need for Speed (top topic: 18)
[18  5 16]
Neuro-diversity and agile (top topic: 7)
[17  7  2]
Java 8 in Anger (top topic: 7)
[ 7 15 12]
APIs that Change Lifestyles (top topic: 9)
[ 9  6 19]
Elasticsearch powers the Citizen Advice Bureau (CAB) to monitor trends in society before they become issues (top topic: 16)
[16 12 19]
Architecture Open Space (top topic: 2)
[ 2 19 18]
Don’t let Data Gravity crush your infrastructure (top topic: 11)
[11 16  3]

So our third talk on the list ‘How SoundCloud uses Cassandra’ does end up being tagged with topic 0 which mentions SoundCloud so that’s good!

Topic 0: time people company did writing real way used let cassandra soundcloud successful know web organization audio lives swift stuck

It’s next two topics are 5 & 6 which contain the following words…

Topic 5: product look like use talk problems working analysis projects challenges 2011 functionality useful spread business deep inside happens sensemaker
Topic 6: ll computers started principles free focus face smaller atlas control uses products avoid computing ground billions mean volume consistently

…which are not as intuitive. What about Java 8 in Anger? It’s been tagged with topics 7, 15 and 12:

Topic 7: code end users developers just application way line apps mobile features sites hours issues applications write faster game better
Topic 15: java using fast robovm lmax ios presentation really jvm native best exchange azul hardware started project slowdowns goal bring
Topic 12: business make build technology technologies help trying developers parts want interfaces small best centres implementations critical moo databases going

15 makes sense since that mentions Java and perhaps 12 and 7 do as well as they both mention developers.

So while the topics pulled out are not horrendous I don’t think they’re particularly useful yet either. These are some of the areas I need to do some more research around:

  • How do you measure the success of topic modelling? I’ve been eyeballing the output of the algorithm but I imagine there’s an automated way to do that.
  • How do you determine the right number of topics? I found an article written by Christophe Grainger which explains a way of doing that which I need to look at in more detail.
  • It feels like I would be able to pull out better topics if I had an ontology of computer science/software words and then ran the words through that to derive topics.
  • Another approach suggested by Michael is to find the most popular words using the CountVectorizer and tag talks with those instead.

If you have any suggestions let me know. The full code is on github if you want to play around with it.

Be Sociable, Share!

Written by Mark Needham

March 5th, 2015 at 8:52 am

Posted in Machine Learning,Python

Tagged with

  • Starry Kate

    Hi, I have read your blog,but I still have one problem confusing me.I don’t know how to get the probability of each words in each topic. I wonder if you can help me.Thank you!