F#: Expressing intent and the forward/application operators
A while ago I wrote about F#'s forward and application operators where I’d looked at how these could be used to simplify code and while trying out Roy Osherove’s TDD Kata I realised that perhaps the choice of which of these to use or whether to use them at all depends on what intent we’re expressing.
The specific bit of code I was writing was for raising an exception if negative values were provided and I originally thought I’d use the forward operator to express this code:
let digits = [| 1;2;3;-3 |] let buildExceptionMessage negatives = sprintf "No negative numbers allowed. You provided %s" (String.Join(",", negatives |> Array.map (fun x -> x.ToString()))) raise (ArgumentException (digits |> Array.filter (fun x -> x < 0) |> buildExceptionMessage))
I think in this case the forward operator doesn’t actually express the intent of the code better because it puts the focus on the digits rather than on the building of the exception message.
I changed that a bit to emphasise the importance of the 'buildExceptionMessage' function:
raise (ArgumentException (buildExceptionMessage (digits |> Array.filter (fun x -> x < 0))))
I thought it might be possible to get rid of the brackets around the filtering of the digits and instead apply that expression to 'buildExceptionMessage' using the application operator:
raise (ArgumentException (buildExceptionMessage <| digits |> Array.filter (fun x -> x < 0)))
That actually results in the following error message:
Type mismatch. Expecting a string -> string but given a 'a array -> 'a array. The type 'string' does not match the type ''a array'
The problem is that it applies digits to 'buildExceptionMessage' first and then tries to apply the result of that to Array.filter instead of applying the filter to the digits and then passing the result of that calculation to 'buildExceptionMessage'.
One way to get around this is to remove the forward operator and move digits to be the second argument passed to Array.filter instead:
raise (ArgumentException (buildExceptionMessage <| Array.filter (fun x -> x < 0) digits))
This is the version that I’ve got at the moment and I think it expresses the intent of the code the best.
I’d be interested in hearing more thoughts on the best way to use or not use these operators in idiomatic F# code.
About the author
I'm currently working on real-time user-facing analytics with Apache Pinot at StarTree. I publish short 5 minute videos showing how to solve data problems on YouTube @LearnDataWithMark. I previously worked on graph analytics at Neo4j, where I also co-authored the O'Reilly Graph Algorithms Book with Amy Hodler.